In the Yanomamo culture, killing is a common occurrence
in the villages, and the likelihood is high that one will know a murder victim.
The rules and consequences, as different as they may seem, also share similarities with the Western culture. For the
Yanomamo, killing often stems from women, jealousy, blood revenge, and infidelity. These are also very similar catalysts in the Western culture as many battles have stemmed from such issues. In the Yanomamo community, when kinsmen are killed revenge will then be sought, which leaves many in the killers
community at risk as the raids often harm whomever they come into contact with. The consequences of killing however
differ as the Yanomamo’s gain a fierce reputation if they quickly retaliate,
often triumph in marriage and reproduction, and deter future violence. For the Western
culture, the consequences of murder are imprisonment, loss of privileges, and a
negative reputation.
The process of revenge killings includes the leader of
the village determining if such revenge should be sought. If so, an attack consisting
of 10 to 20 men will set out to raid the killer’s
community, which often takes several days to get there. Prior to such raid however
women will eat the ashes of the murdered individual in order to help strengthen
the efforts of the one’s performing the raid. After the killings are complete,
the killer then performs a Yanomamo ritual known as the Unokaimou, which helps
to protect the individual from supernatural harm. Through these raids many lives are lost. Anyone
in the village can be attacked and most men that are killed are killed in these
raids. For those that assume the Unokais status, others will know who they are;
they are looked at in a positive manner for their tendency to be violent and forceful.
The Unokais in comparison to the non-unokais find more success in reproduction
and marriage as they are better able to find mates. This however could be due to their reputation
and ability to force another into marriage.
As one can see, gaining the status of a Unokais comes with far greater
benefits than those of the non-unokais, therefore men often choose this route
over the other.
For those in the Yanomamo culture, kinship is the
central force of all things that exist; when this is compromised, revenge killings
then take place. Political structure, social status, and marriage and
reproduction all directly correspond to kinship. The political structure is set up to have a leader
of the village who ultimately decides if revenge killings are to take
place. These leaders often have many
kinsmen in their village as a result of previous marriages between others,
which then lends itself to the likelihood that ones kin will be killed and revenge will be sought. For the
Yanomamo, social status changes as a result of becoming known as a Unokais. They are looked at as fierce and brutal who
will quickly seek revenge for attacking a kinsmen. On the opposite end of the spectrum,
non-unokais are looked at as cowards who do not have the strength to perform a
raid to seek revenge. As far as marriage and reproduction is concerned, their
new social status as a Unokais helps to further their success in these
areas. Men are able to find mates more
so than non-unokais, however as mentioned earlier, it is most likely because of
their reputation and ability to take one by force. Reproduction for the Unokais
is then almost double than those non-unokais, which also stems from their
ability to find mates. For the Yanomamo, kinship is the main source for all
things connected to revenge killings. In
each village, the likelihood of one’s kin being killed is high, which leads to
the eventuality of revenge being sought.
Although the act of killing is often
something that someone does not set out to do nor want to do, it doesn’t take away from the fact that it happens. Many
killers that have killed will most likely say that they didn’t want to do it,
but were compelled for some reason or another. This alone shows how necessary laws are in order to
properly handle these situations in a swift and just way. Without such laws, our political system would
be backlogged by individual case reviews and individual consequences. Without a general system to handle such acts,
we would see upheaval in the community as many would interpret some cases to be
treated better than others. Having set laws that handle situations such as killings helps to create a balanced system by ensuring that there are set guidelines as to how an issue will be decided.
Excellent opening discussion! I like how you emphasized similarities as well as difference. Great analysis through out to body of the post as well.
ReplyDeleteIn your final paragraph, you say, "Many killers that have killed will most likely say that they didn’t want to do it, but were compelled for some reason or another."
Do you think these compelling reasons were very different from the reasons behind the Yanomamo reasons? If not, perhaps it isn't true that we have laws against behaviors people would not want to do. Maybe we have laws to protect us against behaving in the same way as the Yanomamo?
I enjoyed reading your blog, It was very informative and well structured. It was very well fact based through out the whole post. I agree with you about laws being formed to prevent people from acting in against their will. The laws are placed to keep order within any society. Great Job
ReplyDelete